When It Rains, It Pours (also known as Fools in the Rain and Raise the Roof) is a recurring endurance challenge that originated in Survivor: Africa. Considered to be a classic Survivor challenge, it has had numerous incarnations throughout the series' run.


Castaways will have one arm above their head with their wrist tethered to a bucket of water on top of a platform. The castaway who could stand there the longest without tipping the bucket would win. At random points during the challenge, the host may tempt the contestants with food items. They would get the food item only if they step down.

Starting from Heroes vs. Villains, players would have to balance on a narrow perch while trying to maintain their balance at the same time.

In David vs. Goliath, the challenge was reformatted to be a team challenge. The six members in each team must hold up eight sandbags, each weighing 10 pounds. Every 15 minutes, one member must drop out and their sandbag must be carried by another member. The first person to drop a sandbag loses for their team.


The challenge made its debut immediately after the merge in Africa. At various points, host Jeff Probst tempted the castaways with food if they stepped down. Ultimately, the challenge came down to Clarence Black and Teresa Cooper. Clarence attempted to make a deal with Teresa, though she refused his attempts at striking a deal. After over six hours, they agreed to a game of "rock, paper, scissors" to decide the winner. Clarence lost the game, and Teresa won individual immunity.

In All-Stars, the challenge came down to Rupert Boneham and Shii Ann Huang. When asked about secrets within the tribe, Shii Ann said that there were secrets, but not as to who the Chapera Alliance, who were openly rooting against her, was planning to vote out. After over two hours, Rupert dropped and Shii Ann won a vital immunity.

In Micronesia, Jeff Probst again tempted the castaways with food. After over six hours, the challenge came down to Jason Siska and Parvati Shallow. Jeff brought out a large platter of food for the person who stepped down to share with the rest of the tribe. The tribe offered Jason, the clear outsider, that they would not vote him out that night if he stepped down. Jason demanded guarantees from each member of the tribe, who gave them, though no one actually intended to keep their word. Jason ultimately accepted the offer, giving Parvati immunity.

In Heroes vs. Villains, a narrow perch was added for the castaways to stand on to make the challenge more difficult. Throughout the challenge, Jeff Probst once again tempted the castaways with food. The challenge ultimately came down to Parvati Shallow and Rupert Boneham, and after an hour and ten minutes, Rupert lost his balance, handing Parvati immunity and her second victory in this challenge.

In One World, Jeff Probst once again tempted the castaways with food. After over 45 minutes, the challenge came down to Chelsea Meissner and Leif Manson. With Jeff offering a plate of burgers to tempt them down, Chelsea convinced Leif that stepping down would make him less of a threat. Leif obliged and took the food, leaving Chelsea to win immunity.

In Millennials vs. Gen X, the challenge was made even more difficult by having both arms tethered to a pole, with no food temptations offered. Although most of the tribe dropped out early on, Jessica Lewis and Will Wahl managed to last over an hour and a half into the challenge. Jessica then lost her balance and dropped, winning Will immunity.

In David vs. Goliath, the challenge was reformatted as a team Reward Challenge, with each team having to pass around eight bags, each weighing 10 pounds, between them. Every 15 minutes, one member had to drop out and pass any sandbags held to another member. After over 30 minutes, Dan Rengering's attempt at showboating by carrying three bags with one hand backfired and cost the purple team the challenge, winning the orange team of Alec Merlino, Alison Raybould, Christian Hubicki, Gabby Pascuzzi, John Hennigan, and Nick Wilson the reward.


Episode Challenge Type Winner
"Will There Be a Feast Tonight?"
Individual Immunity S3 teresa t
Teresa Cooper
"Stupid People, Stupid, Stupid People"
Individual Immunity S8 shiiann t
Shii Ann Huang
"I Promise..."
Individual Immunity S16 parvati t
Parvati Shallow
Heroes vs. Villains
"A Sinking Ship"
Individual Immunity S20 parvati t
Parvati Shallow
One World
"Go Out with a Bang"
Individual Immunity S24 chelsea t
Chelsea Meissner
Millennials vs. Gen X
"I'm the Kingpin"
Individual Immunity S33 will t
Will Wahl
David vs. Goliath
"You Get What You Give"
Team Reward S37 alec tS37 alison tS37 christian t
S37 gabby tS37 john tS37 nick t
Alec, Alison, Christian, Gabby, John, & Nick



  • Kelly Goldsmith was the first person to lose this challenge, losing 14 minutes into the Africa iteration of the challenge.
  • Will Wahl is the first male to win this challenge. Jessica Lewis is the first female to be runner-up.
  • Parvati Shallow has won this challenge twice. She is the first person to win the same individual challenge on multiple occasions.
    • She is currently tied for the record for having lasted the longest in this challenge with Teresa Cooper, at six hours. Parvati accomplished this in Micronesia.
  • Tarzan Smith lost this challenge in the quickest time, losing only after 1 second in One World.
  • Rupert Boneham has finished in second place in this challenge twice.


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.