We'll Make You Pay

We'll Make You Pay
Episode Information
Version	United States
Season	Palau
Episode Number	12/15 (151)
Original Release	May 5, 2005
Viewership (in Millions)	20.07
Ratings/Share (18-49)	7.1/21
Episode Chronology
Previous	"I'll Show You How Threatening I Am"
Next	"It Could All Backfire"
Subpages

We'll Make You Pay is the twelfth episode of Survivor: Palau.

Story

“	The aftermath of an emotional Tribal Council and stormy weather combine for a night the tribe will never forget. To their surprise and delight, some Survivors are overwhelmed by a visit from their loved ones. A strong alliance leaves one castaway on the outside looking in, with Immunity the only chance for survival. Paranoia sets in as alliances crumble and some Survivors feel like they've lost control of the game.	”
—Episode Synopsis

Challenges

• Reward
• Immunity

Challenge: First Quencher Q&A
Castaways would answer questions about Palau and Micronesia. If they got a question right, they would get to pull a lever, dropping a contestant's torch into the water. After three pulls, that person's torches all would fall into the water and they would be out. Last person standing wins.
Reward: A cruise. After boarding the yacht the contestants found their loved ones on board.
Winner: Gregg Carey (shared with Jenn Lyon and Katie Gallagher)

Challenge: Second Chance
This is an elimination challenge. First up, the final six must go up a tire ladder and traverse a net maze. The first five contestants to make their way to the end of the maze move on. After that comes a sliding puzzle (solvable in 46 moves). First four move on. After that, the remaining four must eat three balut. The first three to finish their balut move on. The final three must untie a box, grab the flag inside, and raise it up a flagpole. First two move on. The two finalists must break three colored tiles with a replica WWII cannon gun. The first person to accomplish that wins immunity.
Winner: Ian Rosenberger

Tribal Council

Tribal Council 13: Koror
Voted Against	Voter
Gregg (4 votes)	Caryn, Ian, Katie, Tom
Caryn (2 votes)	Gregg, Jenn
VOTED OUT: Gregg Carey

Voting Confessionals

	Ian	“	(voting against Gregg) Gregg, you're the dark horse. And it's just time for the dark horse to ride off into the sunset.	”

Final Words

	Gregg	“	I think I'd be lying if I said I wasn't completely surprised. My hat's off to 'em, though. They got me, they got me good. Um, I learned a lot of things. An experience is nothing unless you share it with other people who you love. Jenn, best of luck. I appreciated your friendship out on the island, and, uh, I look forward to…hanging out soon.	”

Still in the Running

Jonathan 20th	Wanda 19th	Jolanda 18th	Ashlee 17th	Jeff 16th	Kim 15th	Willard 14th	Angie 13th	James 12th	Ibrehem 11th
Bobby Jon 10th	Coby 9th	Janu 8th	Stephenie 7th	Gregg 6th	Caryn Koror	Ian Koror	Jenn Koror	Katie Koror	Tom Koror

Trivia

• Given that only Tom and Ian competed in the food eating challenge in "Neanderthal Man", this episode's Immunity Challenge is Gregg and Jenn's first times eating balut.
• The episode title is said by Tom, after Gregg did not choose him for the reward.