Winner Picks
| Season | Winner Pick | Placement |
|---|---|---|
 David vs. Goliath |
 Nick Wilson |
Sole Survivor 53 confessionals 0 votes against Won 7-3-0 jury vote |
 Edge of Extinction |
 Eric Hafemann |
13th Place 4th jury member 14 confessionals 8 votes against |
 Island of the Idols |
 Tommy Sheehan |
Sole Survivor 52 confessionals 2 votes against Won 8-2-0 jury vote |
 Winners at War |
 Ethan Zohn |
TBD |
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.