Winner Picks Season Winner Pick Placement David vs. Goliath Nick Wilson Sole Survivor53 confessionals0 votes againstWon 7-3-0 jury vote Edge of Extinction Eric Hafemann 13th Place4th jury member14 confessionals8 votes against Island of the Idols Tommy Sheehan Sole Survivor52 confessionals2 votes againstWon 8-2-0 jury vote Winners at War Ethan Zohn TBD Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.