To Betray or Not to Betray is the fourth episode of Survivor: Guatemala.

Story

Day 9

On Day 9, a Tribe Switch occurred.

 Brooke
Nakúm
S11 brooke t.png
 Cindy
Nakúm
S11 cindy t.png
 Jamie
Nakúm
S11 jamie t.png
 Judd
Nakúm
S11 judd t.png
 Lydia
Nakúm
S11 lydia t.png
 Margaret
Nakúm
S11 margaret t.png
 Rafe
Nakúm
S11 rafe t.png
 Stephenie
Nakúm
S11 stephenie t.png
 Amy
Yaxhá
S11 amy t.png
 Blake
Yaxhá
S11 blake t.png
 Bobby Jon
Yaxhá
S11 bobbyjon t.png
 Brandon
Yaxhá
S11 brandon t.png
 Brian
Yaxhá
S11 brian t.png
 Danni
Yaxhá
S11 danni t.png
 Gary
Yaxhá
S11 gary t.png

Day 10

Day 11

Anticipating a 4-4 tie at tribal due to former tribal lines, the former Yaxhá members managed to persuade Judd Sergeant to flip on his old tribemates and vote out Brooke Struck, giving them the numbers over the former Nakúm members.

Challenges

Immunity Challenge: Rows And Throws
Both tribes must paddle out and retrieve three of their tribe-colored bags, then race back to shore. Once back, they must untie the bags and dump them into a basket. Inside each bag are Mayan war clubs, which they must then throw at three different tiles. The first tribe to break all three tiles wins immunity.
Winner: Yaxhá

Tribal Council

Tribal Council 4:
Nakúm
Voted
Against
Voter
S11 brooke t.png
Brooke (5 votes)
S11 jamie t.pngS11 judd t.png
S11 lydia t.pngS11 rafe t.pngS11 stephenie t.png
Jamie, Judd, Lydia, Rafe, Stephenie
S11 lydia t.png
Lydia (3 votes)
S11 brooke t.pngS11 cindy t.pngS11 margaret t.png
Brooke, Cindy, Margaret
VOTED OUT:
S11 brooke bw.png
Brooke Struck

Voting Confessionals

(voting against Lydia) Lydia, I think you're one of the hardest workers around camp, but I'm just making this vote based on the decision that we need to win Immunity Challenges.

Brooke


(voting against Brooke) In all of your law classes, I'm surprised they didn't teach how to just be quiet and listen. You don't have to be the most intelligent person to talk; you kept trying to outdo Rafe and what he was talking about intelligence-wise. There's smart people everywhere. You picked a bad jury. I hope you do a better job next time when you're a real lawyer.

Jamie


(voting against Lydia) This has nothing to do with the kind of person you are, because I've already told you you were a survivor before you started this game. You're an inspiration to me in everything I do because of who you are. It has nothing to do with you; it just has to do with tribal ties that happened before I got to know you. Good luck.

Cindy


(voting against Lydia) Lydia, you are an incredible woman whom I have great admiration and respect for, and I'm not sure who's stronger, you or Brooke. But I have tribe loyalties, and I gave Brooke my word, and I won't go back. Good luck.

Margaret


(voting against Brooke) You're a very sweet, wonderful person. I'm happy that I got an opportunity to meet you, but this is nothing personal. I'm just going with the tribe.

Lydia


(voting against Brooke) Brooke, you're an awesome person, but this vote is for strategy tonight. If you go, I have the chance to go a lot further. I'm sorry.

Rafe


(voting against Brooke) You're a sweet girl. I wish I didn't have to do this, but it's part of my strategy to get me further in this game, and it's what I think will get Nakúm a couple more immunity wins, hopefully. See you later.

Stephenie


(voting against Brooke) Brooke, you need to be more aggressive.

Judd



Final Words

Even though I have only got to be out here for eleven days, I did so much stuff that I never thought I would be able to do. I think I proved myself going through the eleven-mile jungle trek, but I don't think my new team members got to see that. I didn't get a longer chance out here to prove how strong I am. I want to wish the girls from my original team good luck. You guys are some of the strongest women I have ever met.

Brooke Struck



Still in the Running

 Jim
18th
S11 jim bw.png
 Morgan
17th
S11 morgan bw.png
 Brianna
16th
S11 brianna bw.png
 Brooke
15th
S11 brooke bw.png
 Amy
Yaxhá
S11 amy t.png
 Blake
Yaxhá
S11 blake t.png
 Bobby Jon
Yaxhá
S11 bobbyjon t.png
 Brandon
Yaxhá
S11 brandon t.png
 Brian
Yaxhá
S11 brian t.png
 Cindy
Nakúm
S11 cindy t.png
 Danni
Yaxhá
S11 danni t.png
 Gary
Yaxhá
S11 gary t.png
 Jamie
Nakúm
S11 jamie t.png
 Judd
Nakúm
S11 judd t.png
 Lydia
Nakúm
S11 lydia t.png
 Margaret
Nakúm
S11 margaret t.png
 Rafe
Nakúm
S11 rafe t.png
 Stephenie
Nakúm
S11 stephenie t.png

Trivia

  • This episode marks the first time this season where the vote was not unanimous.

References

Survivor: Guatemala Episodes

"Big Trek, Big Trouble, Big Surprise" · "Man Down" · "The Brave May Not Live Long, but the Cautious Don't Live at All" · "To Betray or Not to Betray" · "Crocs, Cowboys and City Slickers" · "Big Ball, Big Mouth, Big Trouble" · "Surprise Enemy Visit" · "The Hidden Immunity Idol" · "Secrets and Lies and an Idol Surprise" · "Eating and Sleeping with the Enemy" · "Everything Is Personal" · "Price for Immunity" · "Big Win, Big Decision, Big Mistake?" · "Thunder Storms and Sacrifice" · "Reunion"

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.