Then There Were Five is the penultimate episode of Survivor: South Pacific.


Day 32

After successfully voting Edna out, the final five waste no time in conspiring with Sophie debating on sending Brandon or Rick home next and Albert targeting Sophie for the next vote.

Day 33

Following up on the previous night, Albert is still considering sending Sophie home next and going to the end with Rick and Coach instead.

At Redemption Island, Edna takes a crack at sending Ozzy home and staying alive in the game with her tribe mates supporting her, but ultimately she comes up short. Back at Te Tuna's camp, Albert affirms his alliance with Brandon while Coach, Sophie, and Rick agree that Brandon should go to Redemption Island next as he and Ozzy are the two most dangerous still in the game.

Albert tries to sway Coach his way but Coach isn't interested in sending Sophie to Redmeption. During their discussion, Brandon interrupts and Coach accuses him of being a bully and "being a Hantz". Brandon is offended by those remarks but Coach diffuses the situation. Immediately after Coach comments that now having double confirmation that he knows what he has to do.

Day 35

We open to the Immunity Challenge and much to the chagrin of Coach and Sophie, Brandon wins individual immunity! He also wins the reward of two pizzas which he chooses to share with Rick. Back at camp, Coach and Sophie quickly shift their focus from Brandon to Albert. Sophie approaches Brandon and Rick, the latter of whom is on board with that plan.

With Albert's loyalties in question, Brandon orchestrates a confrontation to determine the truth. Albert's lies are exposed as Sophie and Rick throw him under the bus with heated words. Albert appeals to Brandon, who forgives Albert and even considers giving him the Immunity Necklace!

Brandon talks about God speaking to him and asks Coach to join him in voting for Sophie. A torn Coach replies that he will seek divine counsel of his own and prays for guidance before Te Tuna heads off to Tribal Council.

Jeff and the castaways are shocked when Brandon does indeed give up individual immunity to Albert but his noble deed does not save him as Coach, Rick, and Sophie send him off to Redemption Island. A devastated Brandon hugs Coach before leaving and is told: "it's God's will; go win redemption."


Challenge: Block It Out
The castaways would solve a slide puzzle to obtain a hatchet. They would then use the hatchet to cut a rope which would drop a bag of four cubes with colored sides. The castaways would have to stack the cubes such that there would be no repeating colors on each side. The first castaway to properly stack the cubes would win.
Winner: Ozzy Lusth

Challenge: Batman Wall
The castaways would use a rope to climb a wall to collect five bags of puzzle pieces. Once all five bags were collected, the 15 puzzle pieces would have to be sorted into matching pairs. Three of the pieces would be unmatchable. These three pieces would reveal a numeric code that would be used to unlock a combination lock on a box at the top of the wall. The first castaway to unlock their box would win.
Reward: A pizza lunch.
Winner: Brandon Hantz (shared reward with Rick Nelson, gave immunity to Albert Destrade)

Redemption Island

Redemption Island
Duel 10
Competitors Result
S23 ozzy t
(incumbent inhabitant)
S23 edna t
S23 edna bw
Edna Ma

Final Words

Tribal Council

Tribal Council 14:
Te Tuna
S23 brandon t
Brandon (3 votes)
S23 coach tS23 rick tS23 sophie t
Coach, Rick, Sophie
S23 sophie t
Sophie (2 votes)
S23 albert tS23 brandon t
Albert, Brandon
S23 brandon t
Brandon Hantz
(sent to Redemption Island)

Voting Confessionals

Brandon held his Sophie vote up to the camera but did not give a confessional. Sophie was shown writing Brandon's name down. Albert was shown writing Sophie's name down.

(voting for Brandon) Dumb move.


Still in the Running

S23 semhar bw
S23 mark bw
S23 stacey bw
S23 elyse bw
S23 mikayla bw
S23 christine bw
S23 jim bw
S23 keith bw
S23 dawn bw
S23 whitney bw
S23 cochran bw
S23 edna bw
On Redemption
S23 ozzy t
On Redemption
S23 brandon t
Te Tuna
S23 albert t
Te Tuna
S23 coach t
Te Tuna
S23 rick t
Te Tuna
S23 sophie t


  • This is the second time that the winner of the immunity was immediately voted out from the tribe after giving up the Immunity Necklace, following "If It Smells Like a Rat, Give It Cheese", where Erik Reichenbach was infamously voted out by surrendering the necklace. Erik and Brandon would return on Survivor: Caramoan.
  • On Day 34, Ozzy became the fifth returning contestant to last 100 days on Survivor.
  • As of this episode, Sophie is the only remaining female.
  • Brandon is the first Upolu male to be voted out.
  • The Reward/Immunity Challenge Batman Wall references the Batclimb from the Batman TV show.


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.