Shay started off as the strongest female castaway, Socially and Physically This put her in a strong position with her close bonds with Sala and Avi. But after tribe swap, she was put in the new look Mogotón tribe as the only female in the tribe and was voted out after the rest of tribe threw the challenge in hopes to eliminate her. Their plan failed as Shay defeated Georgia Bergerson in her first Redemption Island Duel which also brought her back into the game and into Merge. She was immediately back into the Majority with new found friend Shannon. But after Shannon elimination, she could not find a way back into the Majority and was voted out on Day 32 even with Avi's Attempt to save her from elimination. She lost her Second Redemption Island duel to Mike and Jak. Where she placed 7th.
How would you describe yourself? Always smiling and laughing. Unless I'm hungry, then I'm always angry.
Why are you doing Survivor? I don't have glamorous dresses so I had to pass on The Bachelor – well, that and I'm married...but more the dress thing. Plus, I was due for an adventure.
What did you do to prepare? I went to FastFit boot camps four times a week to get my butt kicked! I also asked my father-in-law to teach me how to start a fire. After a long day of failed attempts trying Man Vs Wild tricks, I just used a lighter. I still have trust issues with Bear Grylls.
What are your pet peeves? Whiny people and buzz killers. There's nothing worse than when you're having a good time and someone kills your buzz. As a teenager, I remember I stayed late at a friend's house and didn't tell my parents then I got a "you're in trouble…" text from my sister. That was the worst.
What's your strategy? Love everyone, trust no one.
|Shay's Voting History|
| Voted Against|
|6||Mogotón Tribe Immune|
|8||Mike||Jak, Lee, Mike|
|Voted Out, Day 16|
|9||On Redemption Island|
|Returned, Day 17|
|10||Lee|| Jak, Lee,|
|11||Mike||Jak, Mike, Tom|
|16||Barb|| Avi, Barb|
|Voted Out, Day 32|
|17||On Redemption Island|
|Eliminated, Day 34|
| Voted for|
This section is empty. You can help by adding to it.
- Shay was the last woman standing from Mogotón.
- Shay was the first person in Survivor NZ to return from Redemption Island.
- Shay was the first person in Survivor NZ to be voted out twice in the same season.
|Survivor New Zealand: Nicaragua Castaways|