Using only their mouths, the castaways must rip pieces of meat off a large roast animal and place them into a basket. The tribe with the most meat (by weight) in the basket after a given amount of time wins.
The challenge returned in Survivor: Fiji. This usage would be an individual challenge wherein the top three would go on a river rafting trip. The person with the most meat by weight would also receive an advantage to the upcoming Immunity Challenge. Boo Bernis easily came in first place in the challenge and received the advantage. Yau-Man Chan and Dreamz Herd came in second and third and joined Boo on the reward.
In Survivor: South Pacific, the challenge reappeared with a slab of pork. Upolu won the challenge, receiving immunity and the meat in their basket, vegetables, and spices as a bonus reward. Several contestants noted receiving injuries during the challenge, including cuts to the mouth and chipped teeth.
"More than Meats the Eye"
"A Smile, Velvet Gloves and a Dagger in My Pocket"
"Taste the Victory"
- Two episodes to feature this challenge have been named after it: "More than Meats the Eye" and "Taste the Victory".
- In the case when it is a tribal challenge, only blue tribes have won.
- All eventual 5th place finishers have been on the winning tribe.