Pilfering Pirates is a physical challenge in Survivor. The challenge debuted in Survivor: Thailand, where it became the first challenge to allow physical contact between competitors, as well as the first time a contestant was disqualified from a challenge. The challenge reappeared in Survivor: All-Stars.
A narrow series of bamboo walkways connect four boats, two for each tribe. The tribes race to steal items from the opposing tribe's boats, with the first tribe to steal a given number of items winning the challenge. In a specified "attack zone" in the center of the course, contestants are permitted to physically engage their opponents and push them off the course.
The challenge was first used in Survivor: Thailand for reward. During the course of the challenge, Ken Stafford, Robb Zbacnik, Stephanie Dill and Jed Hildebrand became the first contestants to be disqualified from a challenge for engaging their opponents outside of the designated "attack zone", much to the ire of Jeff Probst. As a penalty for breaking the rules, one of Sook Jai's items would be transferred to the other tribe, giving Chuay Gahn an advantage that enabled them to win the challenge, and 24 hours with two Thai Red Berets.
In Survivor: All-Stars, the challenge was the first immunity following the dissolution of the Saboga tribe. During the challenge, Richard Hatch (competing nude) rubbed himself up against Susan Hawk, an event that later led to Susan quitting the game. Ultimately, Chapera won the challenge, sending Mogo Mogo to Tribal Council.
"I've Been Bamboozled!"
- This is the first challenge in which a competitor was disqualified for breaking the rules, as Ken Stafford, Robb Zbacnik, Stephanie Dill, and Jed Hildebrand came into contact with the other tribe outside of the designated attack zone.
- This is the first challenge in which multiple contestants have been disqualified.
- Shii Ann Huang is the only castaway to compete in this challenge twice. She lost both times.
- Both seasons this challenge was used, the highest-placing member of the losing tribe finished in sixth place.
- The eventual winners, runners-up, third place, fourth place, and fifth place finishers of both seasons were all on the winning tribes.