→Winners at War
|}
{{refbegin}}<br />{{note|Idol|<small>1</small>}}<small> In {{Ep|3108}}, Kelley used a Hidden Immunity Idol, negating Jeremy's vote against her.</small><br />{{note|Idol2|<small>2</small>}}<small> In {{Ep|3114}}, Jeremy used a Hidden Immunity Idol, negating 3 votes against him. Also, Kelley used a Hidden Immunity Idol, negating Jeremy's vote against her. Because Jeremy and Kelley both used Hidden Immunity Idols and negated all the votes cast at Tribal Council, a vote restart was held between all the non-immune players. This vote ended with a 3-3 tie between Kimmi and Tasha, forcing a unanimous decision tiebreaker. Jeremy did not change his vote on the tiebreaker.</small><br />{{refend}}
Following the [[Tribe Switch|Swap]], Jeremy and Sele [[Denise Stapley|Denise]] found themselves outnumbered 3-2 by the original Dakal's on the[[ Dakal ]] tribe. However, [[Kim Spradlin|Kim's]] mistrust with her fellow Dakal's gave him hope. When Dakal went to tribal council on day 16, Jeremy joined original Dakal's Kim, [[Tony Vlachos|Tony]] and [[Sandra Diaz-Twine|Sandra]] in voting for Denise, but was shocked when Denise played Sandra's idol (Sandra gave to her) on herself and her idol on him, resulting in Sandra's elimination.
After reaching the [[merge]], Jeremy became apart of Tony's coalition of big threats and won the first immunity challenge. His coalition controlled the first two votes, though Jeremy would have to aid his group in voting out his ally and friend [[Wendell Holland|Wendell]]. When the coalition was splintered, Jeremy was targeted by Tony's new alliance for being a threat. He unknowingly saved himself at the final 10 by using his safety without power to leave tribal council (last time to use it), but this caused his alliance to fall to the minority. Jeremy would continue to be targeted over the next few votes, but was spared at the final 9 and final 8, as Tony managed to keep him and turn the vote on bigger threats. Going into the Final 7 tribal council, Michele gave him her Coin flip advantage to use, but he did not use it, and gave it back to her after tribal council.
On day 31, Jeremy and Michele compared notes and realized that[[ Ben Driebergen| Ben]], whom Jeremy had been butting heads with for the past few days, was trying to create distrust between the two, and discussed targeting him. He approached Tony and [[Nick Wilson|Nick ]] with this idea. Tony however, wanting Ben around and realizing that Jeremy needed to go, began targeting him. At tribal council, Nick sided with Tony's alliance, who [[Split Vote|split their votes ]] between Jeremy and Michele, resulting in Jeremy's elimination. Before leaving tribal council, Tony apologized for voting for him, to which Jeremy replied "bad move". Jeremy spent the next three full days on Extinction Island. Jeremy failed to win the final re-entry duel on day 35, which resulted in his permanent elimination.
|