Survivor Wiki
Survivor Wiki

Anger, Tears and Chaos was the eleventh episode of Survivor: All-Stars.


Day 25

At Chapera, Lex is saddened that not only did he eliminate his greatest ally, Jerri, but it was in the favor of Boston Rob. He assumes Boston Rob will not go back on his word, and he starts chopping wood.

At Mogo Mogo, everyone assumes Amber is gone, and a "mood" is around camp, as Jenna puts it. Boston Rob seems to be the most upset at the possibility because Amber was his best ally and date in the game. He knows he has to "watch both of his shoulders" at all times, and he and Alicia promise to never vote against each other.

In the challenge, Jeff reveals that Jerri was voted out, to the delight of the ex-Chaperas on Mogo Mogo especially when they're relieved that Amber is safe. He says that even though the contestants are still two tribes, the reward will be individual. Rupert ends up winning and invites Jenna and Amber to join him for his reward. During the reward, Jenna, Rupert, and Amber agreed to go to the final three, but Amber already decided to go with Lex, Boston Rob, and Kathy.

Day 26

The two tribes meet up with Jeff, and he announces that the tribes are merging at Saboga beach. Jenna, Alicia, and Amber work on the new tribe's name, and decide on Chaboga Mogo, a combination of the three original tribe names. Lex goes up to Boston Rob and asks if they're aligned, and Boston Rob says "I'll see what I can do". Lex then gets the feeling that he will be double-crossed after not receiving a straight answer.

Rob then goes up to Amber and says that they will pick off the original Mogo Mogo tribe, starting with Lex. Amber isn't sure, considering Lex saved her, but Rob convinces her otherwise. Amber says in a confessional that many deals are being promised from her and Rob to Lex and Kathy, Rupert, and Jenna, Big Tom, and even Alicia.

Day 27

The newly merged tribe goes to the challenge field. Jeff instructs the first individual Immunity Challenge of the season. He also says that there will be two individual immunities. Kathy wins the female's necklace and Rob wins the male's necklace, ensuring that the two contestants from Survivor: Marquesas will not be voted off.

Before the vote, Rob goes up to Lex and says that the deal's off, which highly frustrates him. Lex and Rob then argue and fight over it, and Lex realizes he is outnumbered. He tries to rally Mogo Mogo to vote out Amber, but despite his efforts, Lex was voted out 7-2 and became the first member of the jury.


Challenge: Rock Bottom
The nine castaways are playing individually instead of as two teams. They have to dive down to retrieve a pot. The player without a pot is eliminated. After three rounds, they are diving for a heavy crate in the final, and must take it to shore. Two players are booted in each of three preliminary rounds.
Reward: Overnight resort stay
Winner: Rupert Boneham (shared with Amber Brkich and Jenna Lewis)

Challenge: Waiting to Exhale
This is a standard breath-holding contest with separate rounds for men and women, and thus, two immunity winners. In the final, the two finalists from each gender have to race to unclip buoys. This was based off the first individual Immunity Challenge in Survivor history.
Winner: Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien and Rob Mariano

Tribal Council

Tribal Council 9:
Chaboga Mogo
S8 lex t.png
Lex (7 votes)
S8 alicia t.pngS8 amber t.pngS8 jennal t.png
S8 robm t.pngS8 rupert t.pngS8 shiiann t.pngS8 tom t.png
Alicia, Amber, Jenna L., Rob M., Rupert, Shii Ann, Tom
S8 amber t.png
Amber (2 votes)
S8 kathy t.pngS8 lex t.png
Kathy, Lex
S8 lex bw.png
Lex van den Berghe

Voting Confessionals

S8 lex t.png

(voting for Amber) I'd much rather be casting this vote for your little errand boy, but you're just gonna have to do.

S8 robm t.png
Rob M.

(voting for Lex) Hey, buddy, sorry about the vote. Thanks for keeping Amber around. I hope we can get over this, man.

S8 kathy t.png

(voting for Amber) (sighs) Amber... you didn't have to tell me that Boston Rob and you were gonna bring us to the final six. I just don't like getting lied to that big.

Final Words

S8 lex bw.png

Wow. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't disappointed, but... I came into this game the wealthiest man in the world. I have an amazing wife, two beautiful sons, a loving family and the greatest group of friends a man could ever hope for. Everything above and beyond that is gravy, as far as I'm concerned. Big Tom, you get out there and give 'em hell. I'm gonna be rooting for you all the way. Love ya.

Still in the Running

S8 tina bw.png
S8 rudy bw.png
 Jenna M.
S8 jennam bw.png
 Rob C.
S8 robc bw.png
S8 richard bw.png
S8 susan bw.png
S8 colby bw.png
S8 ethan bw.png
S8 jerri bw.png
S8 lex bw.png
Chaboga Mogo
S8 alicia t.png
Chaboga Mogo
S8 amber t.png
 Jenna L.
Chaboga Mogo
S8 jennal t.png
Chaboga Mogo
S8 kathy t.png
 Rob M.
Chaboga Mogo
S8 robm t.png
Chaboga Mogo
S8 rupert t.png
 Shii Ann
Chaboga Mogo
S8 shiiann t.png
Chaboga Mogo
S8 tom t.png


  • This marks first time an individual challenge has been held during the tribal stage, as the tribes were not yet merged at that point.
  • This is the first time the tribes merge with an odd number of castaways remaining in the game.
  • This is the first time where two contestants are given the opportunity to win Immunity Necklaces at the Immunity Challenge.
  • Kathy becomes the first contestant to win individual immunity in two separate seasons.
  • Boston Rob becomes the first contestant to win their first individual immunity on a subsequent attempt at Survivor.
  • After this episode's Tribal Council, Alicia has improved on her original placement finish; she finished 9th place in her original season.
  • This is the first time the first person voted out of the merged tribe is the first member of the jury.
  • Lex holds the distinction of being the first returning player to be a member of the jury more than once.
  • This is the first time in a post-merge episode that Jenna Lewis doesn't receive votes.
  • After this episode, all the men from Mogo Mogo have been voted out.


Survivor: All-Stars Episodes
"They're Back!" · "Panicked, Desperate, Thirsty as Hell" · "Shark Attack" · "Wipe Out!" · "I've Been Bamboozled!" · "Outraged" · "Sorry... I Blew It" · "Pick a Tribemate" · "A Closer Look" · "Mad Scramble and Broken Hearts" · "Anger, Tears and Chaos" · "A Thoughtful Gesture or a Deceptive Plan" · "Stupid People, Stupid, Stupid People" · "A Chapera Surprise" · "The Instigator" · "The Sole Surviving All-Star" · "Reunion" · "America's Tribal Council"