Amanda Kimmel/Heroes vs. Villains

Amanda Lee Kimmel is a contestant from Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.

Returning for a third time as a Survivor Hero, Amanda worked her way into a power position in the Heroes Alliance. However, after ally J.T. Thomas's elimination at the merge signaled the impending doom of the alliance, Amanda and her allies found themselves scrambling for power, with her getting into a catfight with Danielle DiLorenzo over a clue to a Hidden Immunity Idol, which she eventually ceded to Danielle. Although she was extended one last glimmer of hope when Sandra Diaz-Twine wanted to defect to their alliance, Amanda's fate was sealed when Candice Woodcock flipped to the opposing Villains alliance, ultimately being voted out in 9th place, marking the only time in over 100 days that she was voted out in her Survivor career.

Profile[]

Retrieved from CBS.com

Amanda Kimmel (24)

Tribe: Heroes
Hometown: Kalispell, Mont.
Current Residence: Los Angeles, Calif.
Personal Claim To Fame: "Becoming Miss Montana USA/Miss Earth USA."
Inspiration in Life: "God."
Previous Finishes: China: 2nd Runner Up; Micronesia: Runner Up
Favorite Past Moment: "Finding the hidden immunity on Exile on Fans vs Favs! It was like Christmas!"
Previous Survivor She Respects Most: James Clement (China, Micronesia)
Previous Survivor She Respects Least: Richard Hatch (Borneo, All-Stars)
Why Did She Come Back?: "Because I am really competitive and wanted to prove I could win!"^[1]

Survivor[]

Amanda was a member of the majority alliance on the Heroes tribe consisting of herself, Cirie Fields, James Clement, J.T. Thomas, and Rupert Boneham, putting Candice Woodcock, Colby Donaldson, Stephenie LaGrossa, Sugar Kiper, and Tom Westman on the outside (although Colby, Stephenie, and Tom were in an alliance, Candice and Sugar found themselves in the middle). However, Colby, Stephenie, and Tom were spared after the Heroes lost the first Immunity Challenge when the tribe mutually agreed that the much weaker and more annoying Sugar should leave, and was unanimously voted out.

At their next Immunity Challenge loss, Stephenie was immediately blamed for the loss by James, who viewed her as a bit of an omen due to her losing streak in Palau. The alliance of Colby, Stephenie, and Tom tried to pull Candice and Cirie into their voting bloc against Amanda. However, after a heated Tribal Council, the two women voted out Stephenie, further putting Colby and Tom on the outs.

The Heroes enjoyed an immunity win in the third round, but after another loss, Colby and Tom were targeted once again. Tom had found a Hidden Immunity Idol after the loss, so Amanda and the majority agreed to split their votes between Colby and Tom, so that if Tom played the idol, Colby would go. Unknowingly, J.T. flipped and helped to take out Cirie.

Amanda's alliance maintained their majority, voting out Tom at the next Tribal Council. At the Double Tribal Council, the Heroes unanimously voted out James due to a knee injury he sustained at a previous challenge, saving Colby to be a new member of the alliance.

The Heroes would win the next three Immunity Challenges and make the merge. The Heroes targeted Jerri Manthey, but Amanda told former Micronesia Parvati Shallow that the Heroes were targeting her, although Parvati did not believe it (Parvati had told Amanda about her Hidden Immunity Idol in exchange to know the Heroes target). Parvati shocked everyone by playing idols on both Jerri and Sandra Diaz-Twine, causing all of the Heroes' votes to be nullified and causing J.T. to be unanimously voted out.

Amanda, Colby, and Danielle DiLorenzo won a Reward Challenge the next round and got to watch Treasure Island in the former home of Robert Louis Stevenson. Danielle found a clue to the Hidden Immunity Idol in the popcorn bowl but was caught by Amanda while trying to hide it. Amanda grabbed the clue out of her hand causing a fight between the two women over who should have the clue. Colby intervened and stated that Danielle should keep the clue since she found it, resulting in Amanda being annoyed with Colby for not sticking up for her. At Tribal Council, Amanda was voted out 6-3 when Candice flipped over to the Villains to h vote her out after being persuaded by Russell Hantz.

At the Final Tribal Council, Amanda voted for Sandra, who would end up winning a second time.

Episode	Tribe Affiliation	Challenge	Challenge Type	Sit-Out?	Result
1	Heroes	Battle Dig	Reward	No	Won
1		Lock, Load and Light	Immunity	No	Lost
2		A Crate Idea	Reward/Immunity	No	Lost
3		Sumo in Mud	Reward/Immunity	No	Won
4		Slip, Slide & Score	Reward	No	Lost
4		Roll With It	Immunity	No	Lost
5		Schmergen Brawl	Reward	No	Lost
5		Blind Cube Crisis	Immunity	No	Lost
6		Rope-a-Dope¹	Immunity		Lost
6		Rope-a-Dope¹	Reward	Yes	Lost
7		Basket Brawl	Reward	No	Won
7		Caught in the Web	Immunity	No	Won
8		Fauxconut Bowling	Reward	No	Won
8		Mud Slide	Immunity	No	Won
9		Chimney Sweep	Reward	No	Lost
9		Strung Out	Immunity	No	Won
Tribes Merged, Day 25
10	Yin Yang	Get a Grip	Immunity		Lost
11		Pacific Shuffle	Reward		Won
11		House of Cards	Immunity		Lost
Voted Out, Day 30
Notes: ^1 The tribes competed in separate individual Immunity Challenges where the winners from both tribes competed against each other for tribal reward.

Episode	Amanda's Votes	Voted Against Amanda
1	Sugar	Sugar
2	Stephenie	Colby, Stephenie, Tom
3	Heroes Tribe Immune
4	~~Tom~~¹	-
5	Tom	-
6	James	-
7	Heroes Tribe Immune
8	Heroes Tribe Immune
9	Heroes Tribe Immune
10	~~Jerri~~²	-
11	Parvati	Candice, Danielle, Jerri, Parvati, Russell, Sandra
Voted Out, Day 30
Voted for Sole Survivor	Sandra

^1 In "Tonight, We Make Our Move", Tom used a Hidden Immunity Idol, negating Amanda's vote against him.
^2 In "Going Down in Flames", Jerri used a Hidden Immunity Idol, negating Amanda's vote against her.