Let me know what you think. I will update this again after the next two seasons. My question to you is who would you put in your top 10 players?
Brian narrowly edged out Clay in a jury vote so that hurt his ranking. Malcolm is pretty high considering he's only gotten to the final 4 once in 3 times. Courtney would be higher on an entertainment based rankings but she's not a top 20 player. Yau-Man is lowered by his Micronesia game but he did well in Fiji
you never answered my question on how people like erik r, jay s, and marty are worse players than
crystal, susie, sugar, alicia r, candice, phillip, bret, nat b, coach, corrine, randy, keith nale, adam g and albert
Amarcheterre wrote: you never answered my question on how people like erik r jay s marty are worse players than
crystal susie sugar alicia r candice phillip bret nat b coach corrine randy keith nale adam g albert
Thank you Tuvalu, seriously. Anyway I explained why Jay was low already. Jay did not get a single one of his targets post merge out. He went 0 for 8. Marty did well for 11th place and perhaps he was the version of Sherri (someone who had control pre swap and had to yield it after the swap to survive) that couldn't make it to the end but still I'm happy where I put him. Same with Erik. He had one big mistake but aside from that, he had two average games but nothing to stand out. The players you mentioned that were higher did more I felt or got closer to winning.
better that people like erik r,marty,jay s,jaime d,ali e,laura a,alina,john cody
CASSANDRA IS A GODDESS SHAME ON YOU!
marty didn't give up after the merge though sherri just went running to phillip and did nothing on her own post merge
I didn't say Marty gave up. I said Marty gave up power to stay in the game longer. He did so by giving Sash his Hidden Immunity Idol. That was partially what bought him two more votes (Jill and Alina). Sherri's options were be in the bottom of Cochran and Dawn's alliance or get voted out by Corinne and Malcolm's alliance. One offered no power but safety. The other offered 12th place. Fortunately for Sherri her alliance got blindside happy but she was a key vote in the Andrea and Brenda blindsides. Had the fans had some sort of numbers or unified front post merge, Sherri possibly wins.
Woof. I think you placed too much weight into final standing rather than gameplay. Helen, Sherri, other "goats: rank above someone like Ian? Not good.
What do you think?