Talk:Survivor: San Juan del Sur/@comment-24758540-20140630183252/@comment-7166859-20140709213416

Except we don't have enough winners for a season of all winners. Including San Juan del Sur, we have 28 different Survivor winners. CBS hates Brian, Todd is still sick, Rich is ineligible, Amber & Boston Rob said they won't compete again, I highly doubt Sandra will appear again, Cochran is too affiliated with CBS, Yul has his own show now, Jenna & Ethan have no interest in playing against eachother .... and I doubt a lot of people would want to see more four-time players (ruling out Tina, Parvati, and Tyson). That leaves us 15 contestants who still have a possibility of showing up: Ethan/Jenna, Vecepia, Chris, Tom, Danni, Aras, Earl, Bob, JT, Natalie, Sophie, Kim, Denise, Tony, and the San Juan del Sur winner. Even if every one of these people accepted the offer (which isn't going to happen), it would still be the smallest season of Survivor ever.

If they ever do an "All Winners" type season, I'd imagine they'd probably reserve that for the final season of Survivor ("best for last" mentality).