Board Thread:New on Survivor Wiki/@comment-11184708-20130624063859/@comment-26047483-20150425175144

While it would make for some epic challenges, I feel like it would limit the diversity of the cast in a negative way. Especially if they must be (presumably physical, not mental) challenge threats, physically fit and/or attractive, fairly young, and nice. Incidentally Ozzy probably wouldn't match those criteria as he's not exactly the nicest guy out there. Certainly not the meanest, but in all of his seasons there have been more friendly males. Joe would fit these requirements, as would Malcolm Freberg, Matt Elrod, maybe Fabio and J.T. (although they both won). On the women's side you have Tasha Fox, Kim Spradlin (another winner)...I just don't see that many people who fit all the personality, age, physical appearance and demonstrated physical challenge abilities (even if mental challenge threats are included, which in all probability don't fit all those requirements either) AND on top of that have not won AND can still fulfill the requirements as successfully as their initial season. Take Colby, for example-Impressive in S2, less so in S8, and in S20 he was...to quote James..."Superman in a fat suit" and was considered so little of a threat he was the last of his tribe to be voted out.