Talk:Survivor: Philippines/@comment-4485510-20121011090532/@comment-4485510-20121011212455

"but they had reward and immunity challenges on all-stars wich also had 3 tribes, so why should this season be different?"

Well, my main concern was the strategic part of choosing who should participate. I really only hated the flaw of mixing the two types of challenges together, not the concept itself. If there wasn't any flaw, I wouldn't hate it (obviously lol).

For your question... a reason I could think of for why it should be different... is the same reason why every season with two tribes were different from the Redemption Island seasons, which also had two tribes. :P

But forget that, your solution is way better since it shows more screentime for each tribe.