Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-33309113-20171019161302/@comment-33744391-20171123160037

TribalChants wrote: IMO, Caramoan's the worst season. Most of the "Fans" were not even real fans, most of them were recruited (including Reynold, who surprisingly turned out to be one of the better players despite never having seen the show before) and don't get me started on the "Favourites", most of them were forgettable in their first season (with the exceptions of Malcolm, Corinne, and Erik).

Also, it had the worst final 3 ever in Survivor history (yes, even worse then Redemption Island's F3; at least Rob deserved the win because he wasn't a goat while the other two were). Rob would have lost to everyone but Phillip and Natalie. Cochran would have won over everyone who made the merge. Thus even if you feel Rob's game is stronger or perhaps much stronger than Cochran's which is arguably true, Rob was far closer to being a 3rd goat than Cochran ever was. And Caramoan was a stupid cast but so was RI. Natalie T, Grant, Matty Elrod, Franshitsca (the only ever two time first boot on both seasons), Kristina and Kristina, Stephanie, Ralph, were did they dig up these Survivor rejects.