Board Thread:Discussion Regarding Wiki-Wide Changes/@comment-1294345-20150317141715/@comment-25514305-20150318054642

Ckarimalis wrote:

Before I list why, Ian I must say I find you being very subjective. You are giving counter arguements to all oppositions. You said it simply from the start, support or oppose, that's it. I believe opposition doesn't need reasoning.

That being said, my reasoning for opposition is that I think this info is trivial. It Erin having a ligther doesn't change the outcome of Tocantins. It's irrelevant to the story, and so fourth, irrelevant "trivia" to the website.

Addtionally, this could lead to "conspiracies". This info sounds like the "alternate returning players" fiasco, which, to me, was mostly unsourced or from 1 source, which could just be "he said, she said". Allowing this info to be published  could lead to some saying, for example, "Season 29 was rigged for Natalie to win because there hadn't been a female winner recently" or Idol handing/the like.

It's reality televison anyway, people are typically suspect. I don't think game outcomes are rigged. So I find this whole inclusion of details un-important and clutter. Erinn getting a lighter from the crew may not have changed the outcome of the season, but helping them in their gameplay is potentially game changing. Tyson found the idol because a camera was filming a tree branch in particular, Tony's spyshack was never flimed, that helped him spy and strategize accordingly