Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-24.118.254.88-20140709022515/@comment-25593898-20141029005344

67.252.37.31 wrote: Why not invent a new twist? Hm. Here's an idea. After every immunity challenge, the winning team is given a list of the remaining members of the other tribe. If the person they circled is voted out, that player is actually saved. They swap with a player of the other tribe, and that person is out. If the person is not voted out, they get 1 vote at the next tribal. Makes for quite a gamble. Also, tribes are formed Day 2 like Palau. I think this would put tribes on edge no matter what, increasing tension and strategy, therefore making drama. I'd rather you guys revise my idea if it doesn't make perfect sense.

tl;dr Winning tribe bets on someone. If that one gets out, the person replaces someone that won. If not, extra vote next council. I think this is a really overpowered idea honestly. If you look back to Survivor Season 12:Panama Redemption Island the tribe Casaya had the chance to choose one of the other survivors on La Mina to be immune from elimination and go to Redemtion Island. That completely screwed up the game for the alliance of Nick, Austin, Dan (who was voted out), and Terri because Casaya chose the outlier Sally to be immune. The viewers would not like that at all.