User blog comment:SimBrotherCo/Malcolm - Hero or Villain?/@comment-4752194-20130425172758

What I think is important to realize is that HvV was most likely a one time theme. It took 20 seasons to gather the right amount of heroes and villains and even then, some were questionable (I'm looking at Candace and Danielle).

It was a clever way to separate the All Stars in a way that the winners would blend in a bit more. I don't think they would have the people to do it again without repeating any people.

I think the far better theme would always be brain vs. brawn. Every season has 2-3 in each category, so the crop is expansive. And it emphasizes a different spectrum of how you play the game. It would be more black and white as to what category someone would go into (except Malcolm. He could fly in either group, although I think brains would suit him better).