User blog comment:Ghostsprite/Possible new season format idea?/@comment-26047483-20150211194238

This is incredibly difficult, particularly for the Old Stars section, but here are some additional suggestions.

Richard Hatch (Borneo), Jerri Manthey (Australia), Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien (Marquesas), Burton Roberts (Pearl Islands), Tom Westman (Palau), Chris Daugherty (Vanuatu), Danni Boatwright (Guatemala), Cirie Fields (Panama), Parvati Shallow (Cook Islands), Yul Kwon (Cook Islands)

I know that's a lot of winners, but most winners get to be winners through being skilled players, and skilled players are deserving of an All-Star slot.

Other good options: Rob Cesternino, Paschal English, Sandra Diaz-Twine (because why not?), Stephenie LaGrossa, Bruce Kanegai, Jonathan Penner, Ozzy Lusth, Yau-Man Chan, Earl Cole, James Clement, Amanda Kimmel