Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-33309113-20171019161302/@comment-24593705-20171123202634

Vyortfull wrote: Rob would have lost to everyone but Phillip and Natalie. Cochran would have won over everyone who made the merge. Thus even if you feel Rob's game is stronger or perhaps much stronger than Cochran's which is arguably true, Rob was far closer to being a 3rd goat than Cochran ever was. And Caramoan was a stupid cast but so was RI. Natalie T, Grant, Matty Elrod, Franshitsca (the only ever two time first boot on both seasons), Kristina and Kristina, Stephanie, Ralph, were did they dig up these Survivor rejects., I think you're wrong about Cochran winning over everyone who made the merge... he would for sure lose to Malcolm, Brenda, and Reynold easily and probably even loses to Erik, Eddie, and Andrea as well. I for sure agree that he does easily beat Phillip (crazy person) and Corinne (a complete bitch), yes; the only one who made the merge I'm not sure about if he beats or not is Michael Snow due to the fact I know very little about him.

As for BRob, he deserved his win because of the fact he lost All-Stars (yes, I'm basing it on a previous season). Remember, their was alot of backlash when he lost All-Stars with people saying things like "Amber didn't deserve to win" or "Rob was robbed"!

Oh, I kind of disagree alot of people beat him; the crappy "Redempshit Island" thing was similar to the stupid Outcast twist in Pearl Islands where one outcast, Lillian, made it to the end despite having previously been voted out and not playing the entire 39 days and of course lost! Now think about it, technically, all those people were voted out and sent to "Redempshit Island" weren't in the actual game for the whole 39 Days. If the person who won the final "Redemption Challenge" (which was Andrea) and she made it to Day 39, does Andrea actually deserve to win over BRob? BRob played the entire 39 days without being voted out, Andrea WAS voted out previously. If Lillian made the finals and didn't play the entire 39 days and lost, I think most likely Andrea would lose also for not playing the entire 39 days.