Thread:Sinjoh/@comment-5002930-20190405195714/@comment-4136655-20190406111435

Again, Rick was the one who was given possession of the idol and both of its halves first. There were conditions to the the idol that he had to give one half of it to someone else before Tribal. He transferred ownership of one of the halves over to David, but Rick was in possession of both idol halves first, as well as the fact the idol was found by/given to Rick, not David. Crediting David as who found the idol would be like saying that Andrea found the idol she had in Caramoan, even though Erik was the one who found it ans gave it to her.