User blog comment:Epicrandomtalker2/Returning Players- Yay or Nay? (2)/@comment-2203959-20130419043103

Nay, The reason that we have returning players to "recycle" is because they each were put on a season with other newbies and had their chance to shine, which is what made them great. If we don't give NEW players an opportunity to become NEW All-Stars, then Survivor is going to recycle the same small pool of people over and over, which has already gotten old. Survivor is clearly capable of finding solid casts (just look at the Philippines cast), lets get Survivor back to the way it used to be and start to create a new generation of All-Stars. Just look at the Caramoan favorites, excluding a couple, they're a great group of personalities, strategists, etc. and we didn't even get to see the extent to their greatness last time they played because they were overshadowed by returnees, so lets be done with the returnees for a while, and get some new blood so we can have a NEW All-Star season.