Thread:SummerinGanymede/@comment-108.11.219.83-20121106214245

I'm not sure what you seem to think, but your version of Survivor: All-Stars is wrong.

Alicia, Amber, Rob and Shii Ann won the reward challenge. Then the four competed against one another for immunity, which Rob won.

Your version makes it look like Alicia, Amber and Shii Ann won the reward challenge, and then Rob won a different Reward/Immunity challenge all together. Plus it looks strange.

The Reward and Immunity challenges were together, yet separate at the same time. Either way, Rob won two challenges, and you make it seem like he only won one in that episode.

Wikipedia uses my version as well, if you want to look for yourself.

And for further evidence, Survivor: Exile Island, if I'm correct, used the same challenge. The team Reward challenge winners competed against each other for immunity, which Terry then won. And on that table, it shows that he has won two separate challenges. This is correct.

Thank you. 